BENJAMIN CONEY | Football Coach And Wife With ‘Sick Taboos’ Busted In Online Child Sex Abuse Sting | Sentenced To More Than 30 Years Combined | Autographed Letter Signed

Benjamin Coney. Autographed Letter, Signed. Handwritten, Commercial #10 (4.125 × 9.5 envelope). NW Arkansas, AR. June 7, 2025. Content unknown. SEALED.

A Darkness on the Road: The Benjamin Coney Story

Beneath the ordinary façade of Conway, Arkansas, lay a calculated predator whose sinister online grooming, methodical entrapment, and shameful plot unraveled only when law enforcement caught up. From humble origins to shocking conviction, this is the story of how Benjamin Coney became a face of modern ruthless exploitation—and why his case matters.

Benjamin Coney, born in December 1994 in Conway, Arkansas, spent his early years in a stable, middle-class household. He was raised alongside two siblings by parents who worked hard in local trades—his father a contract painter, his mother a school cafeteria aide. Described by acquaintances as quiet and polite, his adolescence offered no overt warning signs. He finished high school in 2012, participating in debate and a few church youth activities, though he plunged into low-wage jobs after graduation—first stocking shelves at a grocery store, later delivering take-out—but nothing that would have flagged concern.

Despite a lack of notable education beyond high school, he passed himself off online as worldly and learned, with enough tech savvy to weave elaborate grooming narratives. Over time he cultivated associations with like-minded individuals—most notably Emily Grace Brinley, his partner in crime, who shared fascinations of twisted internet communities. Though their group of contacts remained small, their intentions were ominous: they had joined private forums where such urges were encouraged and reinforced.

From November 19 to November 27, 2023, Coney masterminded an online sting. He and Brinley messaged an undercover FBI agent posing as the mother of two young girls. In those digital exchanges, they graphically outlined plans to travel from Conway to Bentonville, intending to sexually assault minors. Over email and encrypted chat, they discussed travel times, location logistics, and even sexual equipment they planned to bring—including lubricants and aides—revealing depraved purpose and disturbing intent.

On November 27, as dusk fell on a nondescript Arkansas parking lot, Coney and Brinley arrived, confident in their plan’s execution. Instead of an opportunity, they found awaiting law enforcement: FBI agents and the Benton County Sheriff’s Office closed in and arrested them. In their vehicle, officers discovered medical-grade lubricants and sex aids, evidence of their intent.

Indicted in May 2024 by a federal grand jury in the Western District of Arkansas, Coney faced multiple charges, including online enticement of a minor, internet stalking of a minor, and conspiracy to commit rape. Court records indicate he pleaded guilty in September 2023—though federal filings show the arraignment in May 2024, highlighting procedural overlaps.

In a sentencing hearing on January 15, 2025, before Judge Timothy L. Brooks, Coney received 210 months in federal prison, followed by 25 years of supervised release. Brinley was sentenced to 168 months plus 15 years’ supervision, their combined terms totaling 378 months.

Though no physical victims were harmed—thanks in part to the undercover operation—the psychological terror is undeniable. The intended victims were two minors, ages nine and seven, each at risk of lifelong trauma. Their families endured shock, fear, and violation, public outrage igniting swift media coverage. Journalists seized the story, prompting national attention on online enticement crimes. The case fueled calls for stronger internet safeguards and spurred the Department of Justice’s continued Project Safe Childhood initiative.

Today, Coney remains in federal custody, serving over 17 years behind bars. Rehabilitation offers little solace here: his crime reflects deep-seated, predatory intent. With 25 years of supervision promised, any relapse into deviance would trigger severe consequences. His presence in prison serves as a caution, but future threats remain tethered to the digital world’s ability to shield minors and the vigilance of law enforcement.

Reflections on Prevention

The Coney case is a grim reminder that predators lurk online, often camouflaged by seemingly benign profiles. Important lessons emerge: continuous expansion of undercover operations, stronger age-verification online, public education for parents, investment in digital safety tools, and inter-agency cooperation are pivotal. Victims’ protections remain paramount—they rely on early detection, decisive action, and systemic policy updates.

A Curious Footnote on Memorabilia

For collectors of true-crime artifacts, an autographed item from Coney—his signature penned under the harsh reality of federal custody—would indeed be rare. The scarcity of authorized memorabilia from modern predators could make such an item unusually sought‑after among niche collectors. Yet this notion forces reflection: valuing infamy poses ethical dilemmas, and any physical connection to such darkness must be weighed with caution.

In the end, Benjamin Coney’s story is not one of redemption but of stark exposure—an individual’s descent into moral abyss, halted only by the unwavering reach of federal enforcement. His conviction reaffirms society’s determination to protect the innocent, but warns: vigilance is never optional.

VIDEO: Couple Busted Trying to Meet Underage Girl for ‘Taboo Fantasies’ Since Wife ‘Likes Them Young’: Cops | https://youtu.be/H1N9GQHh0fE

Archiving Protocol:

• Handled with White Gloves ab initio

• Photo Pages/Sheet Protectors: Heavyweight Clear Sheet Protectors, Acid Free & Archival Safe, 8.5 × 11, Top Load

• White Backing Board—Acid Free

Shipping/Packaging: Rigid Mailer 9.5 × 12.5. The Kraft cardboard is white, self-seal, and stay-flat, ensuring it does not bend. Heavy cardboard, which has strong resistance to bending and tearing, makes each rigid mailer sturdy. These mailers are significantly thicker than those used by the USPS. Shipping cost is never more than it absolutely has to be to get it from me to you.