GREGORY B. MCKNIGHT | Death Row | Serial Killer Murdered Three People in Ohio, Burying the Bodies of Two on His Property in Chillicothe Afterwards | Autographed Letter Signed

Gregory McKnight. Autographed Letter, Signed. Handwritten, Commercial #10 (4.125 × 9.5 envelope). Columbus, OH. May 28, 2025. Content unknown. SEALED.

This is the harrowing story of Gregory B. McKnight: a teenage killer turned cold-blooded murderer whose murderous trajectory spanned a decade. Born in Queens in 1976, McKnight committed his first homicide in Columbus, Ohio, at age 15. Released from juvenile detention in 1997, he appeared to rebuild his life—marrying a Youth Center employee—until between May and November 2000 he abducted, dismembered, and murdered two young men, hiding their remains on his property in rural Vinton County. Influenced by financial desperation? Jealousy? These motives remain murky. His arrest came after police discovered his third victim’s car in his driveway. Sentenced to death in 2002, his convictions were upheld by Ohio’s Supreme Court in 2005. With appeals exhausted, he remains on death row, a rare candidate for execution. His case sparked questions about juvenile rehabilitation, death-penalty geography, rural court funding, and the risks of secretive pioneer life. A piece of his autographed memorabilia would be tragically rare, a disturbing artifact of a mind turned murderous.

The Silence Behind the Smile

Gregory B. McKnight was born on November 14, 1976, in Queens, New York. He spent his formative years in a working-class urban neighborhood, one of several children in a household affected by instability and scant oversight. Sometime in early adolescence, his family relocated to Columbus, Ohio. There, he struggled academically, drifting through local schools with mediocre grades, no extracurricular involvement, and frequent disciplinary disciplinary referrals.

By age 15, he had begun running with a troubled peer group. In 1992, at just fifteen years old, McKnight carried out his first murder: he robbed and fatally shot a man in Columbus—a crime that earned him a juvenile conviction and a stint at the Circleville Youth Center. Prosecutors labeled him a danger even at that age. Yet after serving only five years, he was released in 1997.

Upon his release, McKnight married a woman named Kathryn, an employee of the very Youth Center where he had been incarcerated. For a spell, he appeared to attempt normalcy—finding work at a local restaurant and living quietly in rural Vinton County, Ohio. He formed connections with co-workers, including a twenty-year-old named Emily Murray, and maintained casual friendships—among them, Gregory Julious, who visited McKnight through shared acquaintances.

But over the early spring of 2000, the old impulses resurfaced. On May 13, McKnight lured his acquaintance Gregory Julious, twenty years old, to his trailer under the guise of friendly conversation around 4 p.m. Once inside, he suddenly shot Julious, then dismembered the body and concealed it on his property—burying or hiding parts in the yard and cistern. That body remained undiscovered for months.

McKnight lay low until October 11, when he and two unnamed acquaintances burglarized a residence, stealing firearms. The crime drew scant attention at the time, but it would become part of the broader pattern of escalating violence and secrecy.

Then on November 3, at nightfall, McKnight stalked another twenty-year-old—Emily Murray—his restaurant co-worker. He followed her home from her shift, kidnapped her, and transported her to his trailer. There, he shot her once in the head, wrapped her body in a carpet, and stashed it inside. Again, he concealed the evidence, confident in his rural solitude.

It was not until December 2000 that law enforcement finally closed in. Murray’s car, found parked in McKnight’s driveway, set off alarms. When police searched the property, they discovered her decomposed remains in the trailer and unearthed bones matching those of Julious. His wife Kathryn was initially taken into custody but later cleared once investigators ruled out any involvement.

McKnight was arrested and charged: aggravated murder, kidnapping, aggravated robbery, murder, evidence tampering, and abuse of a corpse. At trial in October 2002, the rural Vinton County jury convicted him of murdering both Julious and Murray, along with related felony counts. They unanimously recommended the death penalty—imposing it for the killing of Emily Murray while committing kidnapping and robbery.

In 2005, the Supreme Court of Ohio upheld both his convictions and his sentence, affirming that the state had proven beyond a reasonable doubt that he committed two separate murders and had concealed his victims to avoid detection. His death sentence remains in place, making him one of only a handful of Ohio death-row inmates.

The number of victims officially stands at two, though the brutality of the crimes—the dismemberment, concealment, and cold stalking—left a deep psychological toll in the Ohio community. Murray, a promising college student, left a family shattered by grief; Julious’s disappearance had haunted Columbus for months. The publicity of the case reignited debate about juvenile crime rehabilitation, the fairness of death-penalty trials in underfunded rural counties, and the difficulty of promptly locating missing persons in sparsely populated areas.

McKnight remains incarcerated in Ohio’s death-row facility. He has petitioned for appeals, citing issues like racial bias in jury selection and inadequate defense representation, but to date his legal challenges have failed. No credible rehabilitation efforts have been documented; he refuses interviews and remains isolated, with little engagement beyond legal counsel.

As for future threats, McKnight remains locked away. But the pattern—early violent acts, a decade of apparent calm, then explosive brutality—casts a shadow over any attempts at redemption.

Lessons from this case are manifold. It shows the challenges of juvenile justice—how early crimes left inadequately addressed can evolve into serial violence. It highlights how rural justice systems struggle to secure equitable trials, especially when funding is limited. And it reminds us how dangerous individuals can hide in plain sight—neighbors in a trailer park who blend into community life until horror emerges.

Strangely, true‑crime collectors have begun whispering about the value of McKnight memorabilia. An autographed letter or drawing from him would be exceptionally rare, a chilling collectible for those fascinated by notorious killers. While disturbing, its rarity ensures high market value among true‑crime aficionados.

Through Gregory B. McKnight’s story, we see the fragile boundary between rehabilitation and recidivism, the stark consequences of failing to reconcile early crimes, and the chilling depths to which a person can carry violence into mid‑life.

VIDEO: Gregory McKnight: The Ohio Serial Killer’s Dark Secrets & Death Row Fate | True Crime Documentary | https://youtu.be/zFMt0j6u30c

Archiving Protocol:

• Handled with White Gloves ab initio

• Photo Pages/Sheet Protectors: Heavyweight Clear Sheet Protectors, Acid Free & Archival Safe, 8.5 × 11, Top Load

• White Backing Board—Acid Free

Shipping/Packaging: Rigid Mailer 9.5 × 12.5. The Kraft cardboard is white, self-seal, and stay-flat, ensuring it does not bend. Heavy cardboard, which has strong resistance to bending and tearing, makes each rigid mailer sturdy. These mailers are significantly thicker than those used by the USPS. Shipping cost is never more than it absolutely has to be to get it from me to you.